Law Practice

Conflict of interest checks for law firms: a how-to guide

What to search, when to run a conflict check, how to record the outcome and what ASCR rules 10, 11 and 12 require, with a step-by-step checklist and a worked example.

LodgeHQ

Editorial Team

•15 November 2026•12 min read

A conflict check searches everyone connected with a new matter against everyone your firm has acted for, acted against or taken confidential information from. Run it before you take the facts, again at engagement, and whenever a new party appears. Record what you searched, what came back and what you decided.

Whether you can then act turns on three rules of the Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules (ASCR): rule 10 (former clients), rule 11 (current clients) and rule 12 (your own interests). Rule references below are to the Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules 2015 unless stated, current as at 15 November 2026.

Which rules apply where

JurisdictionConduct rules for solicitorsConflict rules
NSW, Victoria, WALegal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules 2015 (WA joined the Uniform Law on 1 July 2022)Rules 10, 11, 12
QueenslandAustralian Solicitors' Conduct Rules 2023 (version 2), made by the Queensland Law Society and notified by the Legal Profession (Australian Solicitors Conduct Rules) Notice 2026Rules 10, 11, 12
South AustraliaSouth Australian Legal Practitioner Conduct Rules (SALPCR)Rules 10, 11, 12
ACTLegal Profession (Solicitors) Conduct Rules 2026, from 1 July 2026Rules 10, 11, 12
Northern TerritoryThe ASCR, made by the Law Society NT and in force from 1 September 2025 (amended from 1 July 2026)ASCR numbering
TasmaniaLegal Profession (Solicitors' Conduct) Rules 2020, in effect from 1 October 2020Rules 14, 15, 16 (marked as ASCR 10, 11, 12)

What the three rules require

Former clients: rule 10

Rule 10.1: "A solicitor and law practice must avoid conflicts between the duties owed to current and former clients." Rule 10.2 then stops you acting where you hold information confidential to a former client that "might reasonably be concluded to be material to the matter of another client and detrimental to the interests of the former client if disclosed", unless the former client has given informed consent to the disclosure and use of that information, or "an effective information barrier has been established".

Two details catch firms out. First, "former client" is wide. The glossary includes anyone who previously instructed the solicitor, the solicitor's current practice, the solicitor's former practice while they were there, or the former practice of a partner, co-director or employee while they were there. It also includes anyone who "has provided confidential information to a solicitor, notwithstanding that the solicitor was not formally retained and did not render an account". A short phone call in which the caller explains their situation can be enough.

Second, the consent wording differs. In the Uniform Law states, Queensland and the ACT, the former client consents "to the disclosure and use of that information". Tasmania's rule 14(2)(a) requires the former client's "informed written consent to the solicitor or law practice so acting".

Current clients: rule 11

Rule 11.1 requires you to avoid conflicts between the duties owed to two or more current clients. If you would act for clients "in the same or related matters where the clients' interests are adverse and there is a conflict or potential conflict", you may act only if each client knows you act for the other and has given informed consent (rules 11.2 and 11.3), always subject to your duty to act in each client's best interests. If you hold one client's confidential information that is material to the other's matter, you also need each client's informed consent, either to its disclosure and use or to an effective information barrier (rule 11.4).

If an actual conflict arises during the matter, you may continue for one client (or a group with no conflict between them) only "in the following exceptional circumstances": any client you stop acting for has given informed consent to you continuing for the others, and the duty of confidentiality to all of them "is not put at risk" (rule 11.5).

Your own interests: rule 12

You must not act where there is a conflict between the duty to serve the client's best interests and your interests or those of an associate (rule 12.1). Rule 12 also restricts seeking benefits beyond fair and reasonable remuneration (12.2) and borrowing from clients (12.3). If you draw a will appointing yourself or an associate as executor, you must tell the client in writing before the will is signed about any entitlement to executor's commission, any clause allowing your practice to charge for administering the estate, and, where commission can be claimed, that the client could appoint an executor who might claim none (rule 12.4.1).

What to search

SearchWhyInclude
The clientConflicts with current and former clients (rules 10 and 11)Full name, former names, other spellings, date of birth, email, phone, ABN or ACN, trading names
Related entitiesA company or trust may be the real partyDirectors, shareholders, trustees, related companies
The other sideActing against a current or former client is the core conflictEvery adverse party, including co-defendants, insurers and lenders
The other side's lawyersA lateral hire may hold confidential information from that firm; a personal tie may engage rule 12The firm and the individual solicitors
Guarantors and financiersTheir interests can diverge from the borrower'sGuarantors, security providers, lenders
Family membersFamily law and estates matters turn on relativesSpouse or former spouse, parents who lent money, beneficiaries, executors
Name variantsPeople and companies change namesMaiden and married names, aliases, transliterations, initials, former company names
Your own peopleRule 12 covers your and your associates' interestsPartners, staff and their known businesses or close relatives

Search enquiries as well as opened matters. Under the glossary definition, someone who rang, explained their problem and never engaged you can still be a former client.

When to run a check

  1. At first contact, before the facts. Take only what the check needs: the enquirer's name, the other party's name, any company involved. If you take the story first, the enquirer can become a former client whose information stops you acting for the other side.
  2. At engagement. Re-run with full details: dates of birth, ABN or ACN, former names, related entities.
  3. When a new party appears: a cross-claim, a new defendant, a guarantor, a buyer's nominee, a new beneficiary.
  4. Before acting against anyone, including on a new matter for an existing client.
  5. When a lawyer joins from another firm. Their old firm's clients, from their time there, can be former clients for rule 10.
  6. When a closed matter is reopened or a former client returns.

Victoria's Legal Services Board + Commissioner puts it plainly: "You need to identify and address potential conflicts before you accept a matter and continue to monitor for conflicts as a matter proceeds."

How to record a check and its outcome

A good record lets a principal, your insurer or the regulator see what was done without asking you. Record:

  • the date, who ran the check, and the trigger (new enquiry, new party, new staff member)
  • every name and identifier searched, including variants
  • every match, including those you ruled out and why
  • the rule engaged (10, 11 or 12) and whether you hold confidential information material to the new matter
  • the decision (act, decline, act with consent, act behind a barrier) and who made it
  • copies of informed consents and what you disclosed to get them
  • for a barrier, the screened people, the person overseeing it and the date it started.

Of the rule sets we checked, only Tasmania's former-client rule says "written", but the Victorian regulator refers to "obtaining informed consent (in writing)", and you will need to prove consent if it is challenged. Keep the record client-safe: a note on one client's file shouldn't reveal another client's affairs, and the disclosure you make to get consent mustn't breach someone else's confidence.

Information barriers

The rules require an "effective" barrier (rules 10.2.2 and 11.4.2) without defining one. The Law Society of NSW's Information Barrier Guidelines, which the Law Society of South Australia also points practitioners to, set minimum standards, including:

  • documented protocols for setting up and maintaining barriers
  • a compliance officer who oversees each barrier and keeps a record of every screened person
  • the current client's written acknowledgement that your duty of disclosure doesn't extend to the screened information
  • undertakings from screened people and from the team on the current matter
  • files kept where only screened people and the compliance officer can reach them
  • ongoing education, including sanctions for breaches.

Two limits matter most. A barrier "is of itself no solution to a situation where there is a conflict of interest between one client and another client"; it doesn't remove the duty of undivided loyalty, and then you may act only with the fully informed consent of both clients. And the guidelines warn it "may be extremely difficult for a small firm to demonstrate compliance", particularly keeping staff and files physically separate. Hardship for litigants in rural areas is a factor, but it "does not outweigh the importance of confidentiality".

Common traps

Family law: both spouses consult

One spouse calls, explains the separation and doesn't book. Weeks later the other spouse asks you to act. If the first caller gave you confidential information, they are a former client under the glossary, and in a property or parenting dispute that information will usually be material and detrimental. Rule 10.2 then stops you acting unless they consent or an effective barrier is in place, and in a small practice a barrier is rarely realistic. The fix is procedural: names first, check, then facts.

Property: acting for both parties

None of the rule sets we checked (Uniform Law, Queensland, ACT, Tasmania) has a separate conveyancing rule; acting for buyer and seller is governed by rule 11. The Law Society of NSW says it is not prohibited, but "even with the informed consent, a solicitor must exercise independent judgement to determine whether a conflict is likely to arise even where one does not currently exist". The Queensland Law Society calls conveyancing "an area of practice in which there is a high risk of clients' interests being adverse", says that if an actual conflict arises "you will need to withdraw from representing both clients", and notes that Lexon's policy imposes a deterrent excess where you act for both parties in a conveyance.

Joint buyers are a dual retainer too. On acting for more than one client in the same matter, the Victorian regulator says the lawyer must formally advise the clients of the arrangement and get their informed consent before starting, and if an actual conflict arises, "must stop acting for one or both parties immediately".

Small towns and regional practice

In a town with three firms you will act for and against the same families and businesses for decades. The Victorian regulator notes that barriers may be needed "in regional areas where there may be a small amount of law practices for consumers to choose from", but the NSW guidelines say they are hard for small firms to make effective. Expect to decline more matters, and record why without saying anything that reveals another client's business.

Wills and estates

The Law Society of NSW's view is that you generally can't act for someone challenging a will you drew, "as this would generally give rise to the release of confidential information obtained by the solicitor from the testator". Search the deceased, the executors and every beneficiary before acting in an estate dispute or family provision claim.

Lateral hires

Check a new lawyer's recent matters, at the level of names, against your current matters before they start, and set up any barrier before day one. The NSW guidelines note barriers may be simpler to implement in that situation because fewer people are screened.

When a conflict arises mid-matter

  1. Stop substantive work on the affected matter, but protect urgent court and limitation dates while you decide.
  2. Identify the duty in conflict: loyalty between current clients (rule 11), confidential information (rules 10 and 11.4) or your own interests (rule 12).
  3. If you act for more than one client in the matter, rule 11.5 lets you continue for one (or a group with no conflict) only in exceptional circumstances: the client you stop acting for consents, and confidentiality is not put at risk. Otherwise, stop acting for all of them.
  4. Tell the clients without disclosing one client's confidential information to another.
  5. End the engagement properly: rule 13.1.3 allows termination "for just cause and on reasonable notice", and rule 14 requires you to give client documents to the client, or a person they authorise, on request, unless there is an effective lien.
  6. Record the conflict, the decision, the notices and the file transfer.

Step-by-step conflict check checklist

  1. At first contact, capture names only: client, other parties, companies.
  2. Search every name and variant across current and closed matters, parties and enquiries.
  3. Review every match and rule each one in or out, with a reason.
  4. Identify the rule: 10 (former clients and confidential information), 11 (current clients) or 12 (your own interests).
  5. Decide: act, decline, act with informed consent, or act behind an effective barrier.
  6. Get informed consents in writing and file them with what you disclosed.
  7. Set up any barrier before work starts, with a named overseer and a record of screened people.
  8. Re-run the check at engagement with full details.
  9. Re-run whenever a party is added or a lawyer joins.
  10. Monitor throughout; if an actual conflict arises, apply rule 11.5 or cease to act.

Worked example (fictional)

The enquiry. A two-lawyer firm in Geelong. Client A rings about a property settlement with a former partner, Person B. Under the firm's intake procedure, the receptionist takes only names: Client A, Person B (and B's former surname), and the couple's company, C Pty Ltd. She runs the check before booking an appointment.

The matches. Person B rang in March and spoke with Lawyer 1 for 20 minutes about the separation, but never engaged the firm. C Pty Ltd was a client in 2024 for a commercial lease; that matter is closed.

The assessment. Lawyer 2, the principal, reviews both. Person B is a former client under the glossary: B gave confidential information about this very dispute, which is material to Client A's matter and detrimental to B if disclosed (rule 10.2). B's consent is unrealistic, and with two lawyers, one of whom took the call, an effective barrier isn't credible. The C Pty Ltd lease file is closed and Lawyer 2 concludes nothing on it is material to the settlement; she records that, but the Person B match decides the matter.

The outcome. The firm declines. The receptionist tells Client A the firm can't act and suggests two other local firms, without mentioning Person B or giving reasons. Lawyer 2 records the check, both matches, the rule, the decision and the date.

A variation. If Person B had only asked for a fee estimate and said nothing about the dispute, the name would still match. Lawyer 2 could then conclude that B gave no confidential information and is not a former client, record that reasoning, and act for Client A.

How LodgeHQ handles this

In LodgeHQ Law, every law matter has a parties register: the people and organisations involved, each in a role (such as other party, other party's solicitor, former partner, child, witness or insurer) and on a side (our side, other side or neutral), with up to 10 other names, an ABN or ACN for an organisation and a date of birth for a person. A law matter opens only after an intake conflict check that searches the firm's clients and enquiries, the client of every matter and the parties on every law matter, closed and archived included. Names are compared across all other names; an email, ABN or ACN match counts as certain, and a date of birth settles a name match either way.

Matches are rated by side: acting against someone the firm acts or acted for is rated high (one level lower when only the name loosely matches). A possible conflict needs a "reviewed" tick and a serious one a principal's clearance with a reason before the matter opens, and adding or re-identifying a party runs a fresh check. Every check is recorded in the history on the Conflicts page. Stored checks don't name the other person, and someone who can't open the matched matter sees only that a match exists, how serious it is, and to ask a principal. If the matter involves a designated service, run AML/CTF due diligence at the same intake.

This article is general information for Australian legal practitioners, current as at 15 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Check the legislation and your regulator's guidance for your jurisdiction.

See how LodgeHQ Law runs conflict checks at intake: A$130 a month per lawyer + GST, support staff free, 14-day free trial, no card (pricing).

Frequently asked questions

When should a law firm run a conflict check?

Before taking detailed facts from a new enquiry, again at engagement, whenever a new party is added, before acting against anyone and when a lawyer joins from another firm. Victoria's regulator says conflicts should be identified before you accept a matter and monitored as it proceeds.

Who counts as a former client under the solicitors' conduct rules?

The ASCR glossary includes anyone who instructed you, your practice, your former practice while you were there, or a colleague's former practice while they were there. It also includes anyone who gave you confidential information, even if you were never formally retained.

Can a solicitor act for both the buyer and the seller in a conveyance?

The rule sets we checked have no separate prohibition; rule 11 allows it only if each client knows and gives informed consent, subject always to your duty to each client. Regulators treat conveyancing as high risk, and if an actual conflict arises you must stop acting for one or both clients.

Does an information barrier fix a conflict of interest?

Only a conflict that comes from holding confidential information. A barrier does not cure a conflict of loyalty between current clients, and the Law Society of NSW's guidelines say it may be extremely difficult for a small firm to show a barrier is effective.

Does consent to act despite a conflict have to be in writing?

Rules 10 and 11 in the Uniform Law states, Queensland and the ACT require informed consent; Tasmania's former-client rule requires informed written consent. Get consent in writing anyway, with a record of what you disclosed, because you may need to prove it.

What should a conflict check record include?

The date, who ran it and why, every name and identifier searched, every match and how it was resolved, the rule engaged, the decision and who made it, and copies of any consents or barrier arrangements.

Tags:Conflicts of interestASCRProfessional conductInformation barriersLaw practice management